Compare-Theory-Report All fields 003 | Page Format |
| Number sort to group items | 02.rk |
| Class-Defined | Main |
| Theory-name | Neo-Liberal -Realism-Modified Structural Hybrid - Robert O Keohane - |
| multidimensional approach=Institutional Liberalism |
| Theory-Purpose | incorporate several analytical frameworks or research programs. Includes balance of |
| Power where useful to understand. NAIC Keohane, p3 |
| Note | - should incorporate structural realism = has clarity and parsimony, the range of |
| phenomena it encompasses is limited. |
| - needs better theories of domestic politics, decision making and information |
| processing - so gap between external and internal environments can be bridged in |
| systematic way. NAIC Keohane, P.191 |
| - Modified Structural analysis can provide a context within which an analysis of |
| cognition is politically more meaningful. |
| - knowing maxims of int'l rela theory, must know enough history to place them in |
| context - then useful guides for interpreting events.. |
| - Necessary to remain skeptical of int'l theory and maintain critical analysis. NAIC |
| Keohane, p 3 |
| i====================================== |
| Complex Interdependence Theory |
| The term 'complex interdependence' was developed by Robert Keohane and Joseph |
| Nye and refers to the various, complex transnational connections (interdependencies) |
| between states and societies. Interdependence theorists noted that such relations, |
| particularly economic ones, were increasing; while the use of military force and |
| power balancing were decreasing (but remained important). Reflecting on these |
| developments, they argued that the decline of military force as a policy tool and the |
| increase in economic and other forms of interdependence should increase the |
| probability of cooperation among states. The complex interdependence framework |
| can be seen as an attempt to synthesize elements of realist and liberal thought. Finally, |
| anticipating problems of cheating and relative gains raised by realists, |
| interdependence theorists introduced the concept of 'regimes' to mitigate anarchy and |
| facilitate cooperation. Here, we can see an obvious connection to neo-liberal |
| institutionalism. See Keohane, R. and J. Nye. 1977. Power and Interdependence: World |
| Politics in Transition. Little-Brown, Boston. (2nd edition,1989). From |
| http://www.irtheory.com/know.htm |
| |
| Neoliberal Institutionalism |
| Encompasses those theories which argue that international institutions play an |
| important role in coordinating international cooperation. Proponents begin with the |
| same assumptions used by realists, except for the following: where realists assume |
| that states focus on relative gains and the potential for conflict, neoliberal |
| institutionalists assume that states concentrate on absolute gains and the prospects |
| for cooperation. Neoliberal institutionalists believe that the potential for conflict is |
| overstated by realists and suggest that there are countervailing forces, such as |
| repeated interactions, that propel states toward cooperation. They regard cheating as |
| the greatest threat to cooperation and anarchy as the lack of organization to enforce |
| rules against cheating. Institutions are described by neoliberals as 'persistent and |
| connected sets of rules (formal or informal) that prescribe behavioral roles, constrain |
| activity, and shape expectations' (Keohane, R. 'International Institutions: Two |
| Approaches', in International Studies Quarterly 32, 1988). Robert Keohane is the |
| scholar most closely identified with neoliberal institutionalism. |
| Http://www.irtheory.com/know.htm |
| ================================ |
| Interdependence always carries with it costs - since interdependence restricts |
| autonomy. Can not specify if benefits exceed the costs - depends on values of actors |
| and nature of relationships. Interdependance has two dimensions : sensitivity |
| [degrees of responsiveness within a policy framework] and vulnerability [actors |
Wednesday, 07 May, 2003 | 8:24:27 AM | Page 18 of 27 |